60 votes are needed to approve this organizing resolution. This means that McConnell is challenging Democrats not to blow up the obstruction in disagreement over whether they will promise not to blow up the obstruction. Again: to pass this resolution without Republicans, Democrats would have to change the rules to allow it to pass a simple 51-vote majority. That – in essence – would be to eradicate the obstruction.
What last night told us about bipartisanship
Everything you need to know: After the meeting, Senator Susan Collins, a Maine Republican who is widely seen as one of the most “achievable” Republican senators in this package, released a statement to CNN saying “It seems premature to consider a package of this size and scope. “
In other words: if Biden and his team want this done quickly, they may have to end their goal of getting 10 Republicans to sign up and move on (also known as next week or two) to the next step: a maneuver procedural budget that would require only 51 votes.
A quick update of this great old process: reconciliation
This is a process that requires the House and Senate Budget committees to first approve a budget with specific instructions for the House and Finance Senate Ways and Resources Committees to draft a Covid relief bill. The Senate would then have to approve that budget with 51 votes, but when they do, it will open a long Senate vote that will keep us awake overnight, while members offer hundreds of political amendments.
- Proponents of the proposal need to prove that the bill in question increases revenues or reduces spending.
- That these changes are not merely “incidental”.
- That all changes are within the jurisdiction of the committees described in the reconciliation instructions.
- The senators for your proposal need to obtain at least the same amount of savings as the House bill achieved. And you have to achieve the same goals in the windows of one and five years.
- The proposal cannot have an impact on Social Security.
- The provision should not increase spending or decrease revenue outside the budget window if you want it to be permanent.
Long negotiations are already underway now in the House and Senate budget commissions, Finance and Forms and Means, on which provisions would be acceptable under these guidelines. There is a big debate going on now about whether or not some appropriation provisions would be acceptable (traditionally, appropriations are not handled through reconciliation). There are debates going on about whether the $ 15 minimum wage would meet the criteria. There are many very smart people on the Republican and Democratic side who have been struggling with these issues for weeks. That’s because there was always an expectation that, at some point, Democrats would have to end bipartisan negotiations and do so without Republicans.
Not so fast
Moving forward with reconciliation would still require the Democrats to be completely united. This means that they cannot be just progressive members like Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren leading this attack. Democrats need 100% unity. They need Joe Manchin from West Virginia, Sen. Jon Tester from Montana and Sen. Angus King from Maine, Sens. Kyrsten Sinema from Arizona and Mark Kelly. We still don’t know how these members would vote if the reconciliation process started in the next week or two. Would they argue that there were not enough good faith negotiations with Republicans? We just don’t know now.